Hey Zach,
Bummer about your hat man! I checked with both of the shops here in Missoula that sell Scott and neither of them had the hat in the Navy Blue. However, one of the shops had it in a tan. The owner of the shop that didn’t have anything said you should call Scott as their customer service is amazing when it comes to stuff like this. He said if you told them your story that if there was a hat around like yours they would find it for you. Scott’s customer service number is 1-800-728-7208.
I will continue to keep my eyes open for one and keep you posted.
Moosedog